[This article was first published on Rtask, and kindly contributed to R-bloggers]. (You can report issue about the content on this page here)


Want to share your content on R-bloggers? click here if you have a blog, or here if you don’t.

You can read the original post in its original format on Rtask website by ThinkR here: Signature.py: Award-Winning Application at the 2024 Shiny Contest

🏆 We are excited to announce that {signature.py} is the grand winner of the 2024 Shiny Contest in the category ‘Best Shiny Application with Python’!

This year, Posit relaunched the Shiny Contest, a competition dedicated to the development of Shiny applications. Participants are asked to create a personal or professional application that addresses a specific problem. The applications are then judged by a panel of professionals.

Applications are evaluated based on several criteria: the quality of the user interface, the quality of the code, and the overall technical aspects of the application. The usability of the application and its storytelling are also taken into account.

The competition is open to all developers, whether they are beginners or experienced. ThinkR is no stranger to this contest. In fact, the applications {hexmake} and {wedding} were the winners in their respective editions.

This year, ThinkR decided to participate again. This time, with a Shiny application using Python.

{signature.py}: A Shiny Application with Python

We are pleased to announce that our application, {signature.py}, has been selected as the winning application in the category “Best Shiny Application with Python.” The results and other applications are available directly on the Posit page.

The goal of {signature.py} is to generate email signatures for the ThinkR team. It allows for the quick creation of an email signature using company images and elements. Once all the details are entered, the signature can be directly copied into the email client settings.

Another great feature of this application is that team members no longer need to manually update the banner image. It is automatically updated from the URL where it is hosted. Simply update the image on the server, and all signatures will be refreshed. This is a huge time saver for the team.

Check out the online application: Signature.py

Creating the Application

To create this application, we decided to follow our best practices for developing Shiny applications. These are the same practices we use and teach in our workshops.

Creating a Mockup for the Application

We started by creating a mockup before coding the application. This allowed us to follow the different stages of mockup design:

Creating a low-fidelity (lo-fi) mockup followed by a high-fidelity (hi-fi) mockup.

Lofi

lo-fi mockup

hi-fi mockup

We wrote a blog post (in French only) about the importance of mockups in application development. For this application, we followed the same process.

To build the mockup, we used state of the art tools, and the mockup can be accessed here.

Building the mockup before coding helps us: better understand the user’s needs (in this case, the ThinkR team) and better organize the application’s code.

Spending time on this step certainly helps save time during development.

Building the Shiny Application with Python

For this application, we used the new {shiny} library for Python.

The full code of the application is available as open-source on our GitHub repository:  ThinkR-open/signature.py.

Here’s an overview of the code structure:

Code Structure

The core of the application is located in the signature folder.

The app.py file is the main file of the application. It contains the application’s code.

Similar to our Shiny applications in R, the application is divided into two parts: the user interface and the server.

User interface

The user interface is defined in app_ui. The Python {shiny} library allows us to define the user interface using the ui class, which generates the various UI elements.

app_ui = ui.div(
    ui.div(
    ui.page_fixed(
        ui.head_content(
            ui.tags.title("signature.py"),
        ui.include_css(current_dir / "css" / "signature.css"),
        ui.include_js(current_dir / "js" / "signature.js"),
        mod_navbar.navbar_ui("nav_signature"),
        ui.div(
            ui.div(
                mod_form.form_ui("form_signature"),
                mod_preview.preview_ui("preview_signature"),
                class_="row",
            ),
            class_="container",
        ),
    ),
)

Just like Shiny applications in R, it’s possible to divide the application into several modules. This helps organize the code and makes it more readable.

Thus, the modules folder contains the different modules of the application. Each module is a file consisting of two functions: one for the user interface and one for the server.

Server

On the server side, the application is defined in app_server. The Python {shiny} library defines the server using the server function.

Just like in R, we can also use the small-r strategy in Python.

def server(input: Inputs, output: Outputs, session: Session):
    reactive_values = reactive.Value(
        {
            "firstname",
            "lastname",
            "jobtitle",
            "email",
            "email_url",
            "phone",
            "phone_url",
        }
    )

    mod_form.form_server("form_signature", reactive_values=reactive_values)
    mod_preview.preview_server(
        "preview_signature", current_dir=current_dir, reactive_values=reactive_values
    )

Styling the Application

Here, nothing changes between R and Python. Shiny still natively includes the Bootstrap CSS library.

Thus, we can use the classes provided by Bootstrap to style the application.

app_ui = ui.div(
    ui.div(
        ui.div(
            ui.span("🏆 ", class_="fs-5"),
            ui.span(
                "This project won the 2024 Shiny Contest for the best Shiny application with Python. ",
                class_="fs-6",
            ),
            ui.a(
                "Click here for more information 🔗 ",
                href="https://posit.co/blog/winners-of-the-2024-shiny-contest/",
                target="_blank",
                class_="text-white",
            ),
            class_="container",
        ),
        class_="sticky-top bg-success text-white p-3",
    )
)

This snippet of code adds a green banner at the top of the application, with a sticky position that stays at the top of the page even when scrolling. The banner also has some padding and white text color.

We adapted the application’s colors to match the ThinkR brand in the scss folder and the signature.scss file.

In this file, colors are defined as Sass variables, which are reused throughout the stylesheet:

$primary: #b8b8dc;
$secondary: #f15522;
$info: #494955;
$close: #ff5f57;
$minimize: #febc2e;
$zoom: #27c840;

.navbar {
  padding: 1.5em 0;

  .navbar-brand {
    font-size: 1.5em;
    font-family: "Permanent Marker", cursive;
    pointer-events: none;
    color: $secondary;
  }
}

Copying the Email Signature

To copy the email signature, we used an external JavaScript library: {clipboard}. This library allows us to copy text to the clipboard.

$(document).ready(function () {
  $("#preview_signature-copy").click(function () {
    new Clipboard("#preview_signature-copy");
  });
});

To ensure this file is included in the application, just like the CSS file, we need to include the JS in the UI:

ui.include_css(current_dir / "css" / "signature.css")
ui.include_js(current_dir / "js" / "signature.js")

Signature Template

To generate the signature, we used an HTML template. This template is stored in the template folder in the template.html file.

In R, this would be equivalent to using the htmlTemplate function from {shiny}.

Well documented in R, this feature is currently missing from the Python{shiny}  documentation.

However, here’s how signature.py uses the HTML template:

The preview of the signature is generated from the HTML template. The template is read, and the values are replaced by the ones entered in the app’s reactive value reactive_values. This reactive value is initialized in app.py and passed to the modules mod_form and mod_preview.

reactive_values = reactive.Value(
  {
    "firstname",
    "lastname",
    "jobtitle",
    "email",
    "email_url",
    "phone",
    "phone_url",
  }
)

As the user fills in the form, the reactive value is updated.

@module.server
def form_server(input: Inputs, output: Outputs, session: Session, reactive_values):
    @reactive.effect
    @reactive.event(
        input.firstname, input.lastname, input.job_title, input.email, input.phone
    )
    def _():
        reactive_values.set(
            {
                "firstname": input.firstname(),
                "lastname": input.lastname(),
                "job_title": input.job_title(),
                "email": input.email(),
                "email_url": f"mailto:{input.email()}",
                "phone": input.phone(),
                "phone_url": f"tel:{input.phone()}",
            }
        )

Finally, the template is read, and the values are replaced by the entered values. To do this, we use the Python {jinja2} library. We fetch the template and the entered values, then pass them to the template.

The template is then rendered in the application.

def preview_server(
    input: Inputs, output: Outputs, session: Session, current_dir, reactive_values
):
    env = Environment(loader=FileSystemLoader(current_dir))
    template = env.get_template("template/template.html")

    @render.text
    def render_template() -> str:
        print(reactive_values())

        first_name = reactive_values().get("firstname")
        last_name = reactive_values().get("lastname")
        job_title = reactive_values().get("job_title")
        email = reactive_values().get("email")
        email_url = reactive_values().get("email_url")
        phone = reactive_values().get("phone")
        phone_url = reactive_values().get("phone_url")

        rendered_template = template.render(
            firstname="{{firstname}}" if first_name == "" else first_name,
            lastname="{{lastname}}" if last_name == "" else last_name,
            job_title="{{job_title}}" if job_title == "" else job_title,
            email="{{email}}" if email == "" else email,
            phone="{{phone}}" if phone == "" else phone,
            email_url="{{email_url}}" if email_url == "" else email_url,
            phone_url="{{phone_url}}" if phone_url == "" else phone_url,
        )
        return rendered_template

Tests

We continue to follow the best development practices that we know in R and reuse them in Python. We used the {pytest} library to write unit tests.

The tests are stored in the tests/pytest-unit folder, with the files test_accordion_panels.py, test_one_plus_one.py (got to start somewhere).

Here, we are performing unit tests. This means we focus on testing a specific function or module. The goal is to test the behavior of a function rather than the behavior of the entire application. These tests are primarily business/domain-related tests.

A Python test looks like this:

def test_one_plus_one():
    assert 1 + 1 == 2

In parallel, we also wrote End-to-End (E2E) tests. These tests allow us to test the entire application. They help ensure that the application works correctly as a whole. The objective here is to simulate user behavior. To do this, we use the {playwright} library, which allows us to simulate user interactions.

These tests ensure that the application works correctly as a whole by testing the integration of different modules. Unlike unit tests, which focus on isolated functions or components, E2E tests simulate a complete user scenario. For example, they can verify that filling out a form properly updates the data and generates a correct signature. This helps detect errors that might arise during interactions between modules, thus enhancing the overall reliability and user experience of the application.

E2E tests are stored in the tests/pytest-playwright folder, in the file test_e2e.py.

An E2E test in Python looks like this:

from shiny.run import ShinyAppProc
from playwright.sync_api import Page, expect
from shiny.pytest import create_app_fixture

app = create_app_fixture("../../app.py")


def test_signature(page: Page, app: ShinyAppProc):
    page.goto(app.url)
    response = page.request.get(app.url)
    expect(response).to_be_ok()
    expect(page).to_have_title("signature.py")

Continuous Integration

All the way through, we adhere to best development practices. We also set up a continuous integration pipeline for this application.

The continuous integration pipeline is stored in the .github/workflows/run-pytest.yaml file. This file contains the different steps of the pipeline.

Each time a push is made to the GitHub repository, the pipeline is triggered. It runs the unit tests and the E2E tests. If the tests pass, the pipeline turns green. If not, it turns red.

name: Unit tests + E2E tests

jobs:
  pytest:
    runs-on: ubuntu-latest

    steps:

      ...

      - name: 🧪 Run tests
        run: poetry run pytest --github-report -vvv --browser webkit --browser chromium --browser firefox

This is a great way to ensure that the application works correctly before deploying it to production. Here, the application is tested on three browsers: Webkit, Chromium, and Firefox.

Updating the Banner Imager

To update the banner image, simply update the image in the GitHub repository. The image is stored in the signature/assets folder, in the file current_banner.png.

Once the image is updated, it will directly impact the application and all the signatures generated with the app.

Deploying the Application on Our Servers

This application is deployed on our servers. You can view it online: signature.py.

This Python application lives alongside our other R applications on our servers. Feel free to contact us if you want to deploy your Python or R applications to production.

Going Further

R and Python: the battle between these two programming languages is an endless debate. Why choose between one or the other? Why not use both?

We also created this Python application in R. You can view the application online: signature.r.

But we also created it in Vanilla JavaScript. You can check out the application here: signature.js.

Whether for the R, Python, or JavaScript application, the source codes are available on our GitHub repository. Explore the code for ThinkR-open/signature.py,  ThinkR-open/signature.r or ThinkR-open/signature.js.

If you’d like to reuse this application for yourself, clone these applications and customize them to suit your needs! You may need to adjust it to your company by modifying the images and possibly the text and colors.

You can also contact us for help adapting this application to your needs. We’ll be happy to assist.

With {signature.py}, we wanted to test the promising new {shiny} library for Python. That’s done, and we are thrilled with this experience. In the end, we were able to reproduce it in R and JavaScript. A sign that Shiny applications meet a need, and programming languages are just tools to address that need.

This post is better presented on its original ThinkR website here: Signature.py: Award-Winning Application at the 2024 Shiny Contest

To leave a comment for the author, please follow the link and comment on their blog: Rtask.

R-bloggers.com offers daily e-mail updates about R news and tutorials about learning R and many other topics. Click here if you’re looking to post or find an R/data-science job.


Want to share your content on R-bloggers? click here if you have a blog, or here if you don’t.

Continue reading: Signature.py: Award-Winning Application at the 2024 Shiny Contest

Insights and Potential Future Developments of signature.py

The signature.py application developed by ThinkR was the grand winner of the 2024 Shiny Contest, in the category of ‘Best Shiny Application with Python’. This application’s key function is to generate email signatures for the ThinkR team and addresses several efficiency issues in the process. It’s award-winning status is a testament to the well-executed combination of user-friendly features, solid code quality, and effective storytelling. Considering the implication of this success, it’s clear that applications that streamline routine tasks while ensuring uniformity have immense potential.

Forecasting Future Developments

Looking ahead, there could be potential for further enhancements made to signature.py or perhaps applications with similar functionality. Development efforts may center around streamlining the user interface even more, enhancing accessibility, or incorporating additional features such as a create-and-save option for multiple signature templates. Given the app’s open-source foundation, future contributors can step up to extend its capabilities according to the evolving needs of users.

Implications of Development Practices

The success of signature.py also underscores the value of the development techniques used by ThinkR. Their practices such as creation of high-fidelity mockups before coding, use of Python’s shiny library, and rigorous unit and end-to-end tests underscored the overall effectiveness of the app while ensuring its reliability. These practices could serve as a model for other developers aiming to create smooth-running, error-free applications.

Considerations for Developers

Learning from the success of signature.py, developers may want to consider the following points while planning future applications:

  • Applicability: Prioritize making applications that solve a common problem or automate a frequent task. Such applications are likely to have a larger user base.
  • Code Quality: Ensure the code is of high quality, well-structured, and easy to understand. This not only improves the functionality of the application, but also allows other contributors to understand and work on the code more effectively.
  • Testing: Implement comprehensive unit and end-to-end testing to catch any errors early in the development phase, ensuring the dependability of the application.
  • End-User Experience: Create a simple and efficient user interface to enhance the user experience. Consequently, it can increase the adoption rate of the application.

Actionable Insights

For Businesses

Consider using or adapting applications like signature.py to automate routine tasks in your organization and increase overall efficiency. It would be beneficial to have applications customized to fully align and represent your brand. This includes adjusting the images and modifying the text, colors, and any other necessary aspects to make it a perfect fit for your company. Don’t hesitate to seek professional help for customization if needed and ensure you deploy your apps in a secure environment.

For Developers and Communities

Engage with the open-source community and share your unique solutions to common problems. Participate in contests such as the Shiny Contest to raise your profile and gain valuable feedback on your coding skills. This can also be a platform to learn from others, as developers open-source their code and discuss their methodology.

Conclusion

ThinkR’s signature.py holds a beacon for future developments in automation and efficiency-enhancing tools. It stands as an example of streamlined functionality, well-structured, high-quality code, and comprehensive testing practices that result in an effective, award-winning application. As the world progresses further into the digital age, such tools will continue to play an increasingly significant role in streamlining business operations. As a part of this journey, developers can learn from successful examples such as signature.py to build better, more efficient applications that significantly contribute to the future of digital workspaces.

Read the original article