Harmony and Dissonance: Orphism in Paris, 1910–1930

Future Trends in Non-Objective Painting: A Comprehensive Analysis

In the world of art, movements and isms have always played a crucial role in defining and shaping artistic trends. One such movement, Orphism, also known as Orphic Cubism, emerged in Paris in the early 20th century. While it remains relatively understudied and misapprehended compared to other modernist movements such as Futurism, Vorticism, and Cubism, the recent exhibition at the Guggenheim Museum titled “Harmony and Dissonance: Orphism in Paris, 1910–1930” sheds new light on the potential future trends within this artistic movement.

Orphism, coined by the French poet and critic Guillaume Apollinaire in 1912, draws inspiration from the mythical figure of Orpheus and his ability to convey emotions through music. Like the Cubists, Orphic painters aimed to liberate pictorial form and color from figurative duties and create “pure painting.” The movement’s unique quality lies in its fusion of literary allusion and visual art, making it a fascinating subject for further exploration.

One key trend that emerges from the exhibition is the international nature of Orphism. Although developed predominantly in Paris, Orphism attracted artists of diverse backgrounds and nationalities. From Germany to Italy to the United States, artists explored “pure” form and color, resonating with the aesthetic achievements of Orphism. This trend suggests that nonobjective painting’s appeal transcended geographical boundaries and captivated artists worldwide.

Another trend highlighted in the exhibition is the influence of music on Orphic painting. Music, particularly its compositional techniques, served as a guiding force for many Orphic painters. The concept of simultaneity in music, where chords exist simultaneously rather than linearly, resonated with the visual effects that artists sought to achieve. The indissoluble coupling of music and dance also played a role in influencing Orphism’s pictorial tendencies, blurring the lines between figure and ground in their artworks.

Optical ambition emerges as a fundamental characteristic of Orphic painters. Influenced by post-Impressionist innovations and scientific color theories, particularly those by Georges Seurat and Paul Signac, the Delaunays, who were closely associated with Orphism, constructed their images based on contrasts. These contrasts extended beyond the ocular or chromatic and were affective responses to the conditions of modern urban life. The rise of cinema, commercialism, and mechanization in the metropolis influenced the hallucinatory swirls of color and forms in Orphic paintings.

Highlighted in the exhibition is the influence of urban life on Orphism, with particular emphasis on the Eiffel Tower as a symbol of modernity. Robert Delaunay’s depiction of the Eiffel Tower increasingly dematerialized, contributing to the movement’s blurring of figuration and abstraction. The exhibition also sheds light on the collaborations between artists, illustrating the impact of the Delaunays on painters such as Eduardo Viana and Amadeo de Souza-Cardoso. These collaborations demonstrate how Orphism transcended individual artists and became a collective movement, influencing artistic practices across borders.

Despite the exhibition’s success in contextualizing Orphism and its aesthetic achievements, there are some shortcomings. The inclusion of works from other movements such as Cubism, Futurism, and Vorticism alongside Orphism could leave the uninitiated visitor uncertain about the precise content and consequences of Orphism. This dilution of focus risks rendering Orphism a bit of everything and, therefore, nothing in particular.

As we look towards the future of nonobjective painting, the potential trends emerging from Orphism offer valuable insights. The international nature of Orphism implies that nonobjective painting will continue to attract artists from diverse backgrounds who seek to explore the possibilities of form and color. The influence of music on Orphic painting suggests that artists will continue to draw inspiration from other art forms and cross disciplines to create innovative works. Furthermore, the emphasis on optical ambition and the affective response to modern life implies that artists will continue to seek ways to capture the essence of our ever-evolving society.

In conclusion, the recent exhibition “Harmony and Dissonance: Orphism in Paris, 1910–1930” sheds light on potential future trends in nonobjective painting. Drawing on international influences, music, and the response to modern urban life, Orphism offers valuable insights into the direction of nonobjective art. As artists continue to experiment and push the boundaries of form and color, nonobjective painting is set to evolve and captivate audiences worldwide.

References:
1. McNaught, M. (2019). Harmony and Dissonance: Orphism in Paris, 1910–1930. Guggenheim. Retrieved from https://www.guggenheim.org/exhibition/harmony-and-dissonance-orphism-in-paris-1910-1930