by jsendak | Apr 22, 2024 | GR & QC Articles
arXiv:2404.12424v1 Announce Type: new
Abstract: We numerically investigate the imprints of gravitational radiation-reaction driven changes to a black hole’s mass and spin on the corresponding ringdown waveform. We do so by comparing the dynamics of a perturbed black hole evolved with the full (nonlinear) versus linearized Einstein equations. As expected, we find that the quasinormal mode amplitudes extracted from nonlinear evolution deviate from their linear counterparts at third order in initial perturbation amplitude. For perturbations leading to a change in the black hole mass and spin of $sim 5%$, which is reasonable for a remnant formed in an astrophysical merger, we find that nonlinear distortions to the complex amplitudes of some quasinormal modes can be as large as $sim 50%$ at the peak of the waveform. Furthermore, the change in the mass and spin results in a drift in the quasinormal mode frequencies, which for large amplitude perturbations causes the nonlinear waveform to rapidly dephase with respect to its linear counterpart. %These two nonlinear effects together create a large distortion in both the amplitude and phase of the ringdown gravitational waveform. Surprisingly, despite these nonlinear effects creating significant deviations in the nonlinear waveform, we show that a linear quasinormal mode model still performs quite well from close to the peak amplitude onwards.
Examining the Conclusions
The article investigates the impact of gravitational radiation-reaction driven changes to a black hole’s mass and spin on the corresponding ringdown waveform. The study compares the dynamics of a perturbed black hole evolved using the full (nonlinear) Einstein equations and the linearized Einstein equations. The following conclusions are drawn:
- Nonlinear evolution produces deviations in the quasinormal mode amplitudes at the third order in the initial perturbation amplitude.
- Perturbations leading to a ~5% change in the black hole mass and spin (as expected in an astrophysical merger) result in nonlinear distortions of complex amplitudes of some quasinormal modes reaching ~50% at the peak of the waveform.
- The change in mass and spin causes a drift in the quasinormal mode frequencies, causing the nonlinear waveform to rapidly dephase compared to the linear waveform.
- Despite significant deviations in the nonlinear waveform caused by these effects, a linear quasinormal mode model still performs well from close to the peak amplitude onwards.
Future Roadmap
Challenges
- Understanding the nonlinearity of black hole dynamics and its impact on ringdown waveforms.
- Quantifying the effects of gravitational radiation-reaction on the mass and spin of black holes in astrophysical mergers.
- Characterizing the nonlinear distortions in quasinormal mode amplitudes and frequencies and their implications for waveform analysis.
Opportunities
- Refining numerical techniques for accurately simulating black hole dynamics and ringdown waveforms.
- Exploring the limits of linear models in capturing important features of nonlinear waveform behavior.
- Investigating the potential applications of nonlinear distortions in quasinormal mode amplitudes and frequencies for gravitational wave detection and analysis.
Conclusion
This study highlights the nonlinear effects of gravitational radiation-reaction on the ringdown waveform of black holes. While nonlinear distortions in the waveform are significant, a linear quasinormal mode model still performs well for analysis close to the peak amplitude. However, understanding and quantifying these nonlinear effects present challenges and opportunities for future research in black hole dynamics and gravitational wave analysis.
Read the original article
by jsendak | Apr 9, 2024 | GR & QC Articles
arXiv:2404.04447v1 Announce Type: new
Abstract: We calculate the quasinormal modes of a nonsingular spherically symmetric black hole effective model with holonomy corrections. The model is based on quantum corrections inspired by loop quantum gravity. It is covariant and results in a spacetime that is regular everywhere with a parameter-dependent black bounce.
Perturbations of these black holes due to massless scalar and electromagnetic fields have been previously calculated and some intriguing results were observed. For some modes, the frequency versus minimum-radius parameter trajectories were found to spiral and self-intersect in the complex plane. In addition, the spectrum of overtones has real frequencies that oscillate with increasing overtone number, and may even vanishing for some overtones.
We have calculated the quasinormal modes for all massless spin perturbations, including spin-1/2, and axial- and polar-gravitational. We find that the trajectory-spirals are restricted to scalar perturbations and observe some interesting overtone behaviour for gravitational perturbations. The amount of isospectrality violation in the gravitational quasinormal mode spectra is also examined.
Conclusions
The authors of the article have calculated the quasinormal modes of a nonsingular spherically symmetric black hole effective model with holonomy corrections. They have found some intriguing results for the perturbations of these black holes, including spiral and self-intersecting trajectories in the complex plane for some modes, oscillating frequencies for overtones, and isospectrality violation in the gravitational quasinormal mode spectra.
Future Roadmap
Challenges
- Further investigation is needed to understand the underlying mechanisms that lead to the observed trajectory-spirals and self-intersections in the complex plane. This may involve exploring the role of quantum corrections inspired by loop quantum gravity in shaping the behavior of the quasinormal modes.
- Understanding the physical implications and significance of the oscillating frequencies for overtones is another challenge that requires careful analysis. It is important to determine whether this behavior is a generic feature of the model or specific to certain perturbations.
- The examination of isospectrality violation in the gravitational quasinormal mode spectra requires more in-depth study. It is crucial to understand the implications of this violation and its potential consequences for black hole physics.
Opportunities
- The observed trajectory-spirals and self-intersections in the complex plane for scalar perturbations open up new avenues for research. Investigating the implications of these unique features can provide insights into the behavior of black holes with holonomy corrections.
- The oscillating frequencies for overtones present an opportunity to better understand the nature of these black holes and their response to perturbations. Exploring the connection between overtone behavior and the model parameters can shed light on the underlying physics.
- Studying the isospectrality violation in the gravitational quasinormal mode spectra can provide valuable information about the limits and constraints of the model. This violation may indicate deviations from conventional black hole behavior and could potentially lead to new theoretical frameworks.
Roadmap
- Conduct further research to elucidate the origin and implications of the trajectory-spirals and self-intersections in the complex plane for scalar perturbations. Analyze the role of quantum corrections inspired by loop quantum gravity in shaping these features.
- Investigate the oscillating frequencies for overtones in more detail, exploring their dependence on model parameters and perturbation types. Determine if this behavior is generic or specific to certain perturbations.
- Deepen the examination of isospectrality violation in the gravitational quasinormal mode spectra, exploring its consequences for the black hole effective model with holonomy corrections and its implications for black hole physics.
- Explore potential extensions or modifications to the current model that could address the challenges and opportunities identified. Develop new theoretical frameworks to accommodate the observed phenomena and provide a comprehensive understanding of the nonsingular spherically symmetric black hole system.
Read the original article
by jsendak | Mar 19, 2024 | GR & QC Articles
arXiv:2403.10605v1 Announce Type: new
Abstract: We study the physics of photon rings in a wide range of axisymmetric black holes admitting a separable Hamilton-Jacobi equation for the geodesics. Utilizing the Killing-Yano tensor, we derive the Penrose limit of the black holes, which describes the physics near the photon ring. The obtained plane wave geometry is directly linked to the frequency matrix of the massless wave equation, as well as the instabilities and Lyapunov exponents of the null geodesics. Consequently, the Lyapunov exponents and frequencies of the photon geodesics, along with the quasinormal modes, can be all extracted from a Hamiltonian in the Penrose limit plane wave metric. Additionally, we explore potential bounds on the Lyapunov exponent, the orbital and precession frequencies, in connection with the corresponding inverted harmonic oscillators and we discuss the possibility of photon rings serving as holographic horizons in a holographic duality framework for astrophysical black holes. Our formalism is applicable to spacetimes encompassing various types of black holes, including stationary ones like Kerr, Kerr-Newman, as well as static black holes such as Schwarzschild, Reissner-Nordstr”om, among others.
Future Roadmap: Challenges and Opportunities on the Horizon
Introduction
In this study, we delve into the fascinating realm of photon rings in a diverse range of axisymmetric black holes. Our primary objective is to examine the physics of these photon rings and explore the potential applications and possibilities they offer. We also discuss the relevance of our findings to various black hole types and their implications in astrophysical scenarios. Below, we outline a future roadmap for readers, highlighting the challenges and opportunities on the horizon.
Understanding the Physics of Photon Rings
To comprehend the physics behind photon rings, we start by investigating black holes that allow for a separable Hamilton-Jacobi equation for the geodesics. Through careful analysis and utilization of the Killing-Yano tensor, we obtain the Penrose limit of these black holes. This important result describes the physics occurring near the photon ring, a crucial region of interest.
Linking the Plane Wave Geometry and Wave Equation
The obtained plane wave geometry is directly linked to the frequency matrix of the massless wave equation. By studying these connections, we gain insights into the instabilities and Lyapunov exponents of the null geodesics. These Lyapunov exponents and frequencies of photon geodesics, along with the quasinormal modes, can be extracted from the Hamiltonian in the Penrose limit plane wave metric.
Potential Bounds and Inverted Harmonic Oscillators
We further explore the potential bounds on the Lyapunov exponent, the orbital and precession frequencies. We establish connections between these quantities and corresponding inverted harmonic oscillators. This analysis offers intriguing possibilities for understanding the behavior and limitations of photon rings in different black hole spacetimes.
Holographic Duality Framework for Astrophysical Black Holes
Our investigation also delves into the concept of holographic horizons and their applicability to astrophysical black holes. We examine the potential of photon rings serving as holographic horizons within a holographic duality framework. This framework opens up new avenues for understanding the nature of black holes and their connection to holography.
Applicability to Various Black Hole Types
Our formalism is applicable to a wide range of black hole types. We consider stationary black holes like Kerr and Kerr-Newman, as well as static black holes such as Schwarzschild and Reissner-Nordström, among others. This broad applicability enhances the relevance and potential impact of our findings in diverse astrophysical scenarios.
Conclusion
By delving into the physics of photon rings in a range of axisymmetric black holes, we have uncovered valuable insights and potential applications. Our investigation into the Penrose limit, the relationship to frequency matrices and Lyapunov exponents, as well as the exploration of holographic horizons, sets the stage for exciting future research. Despite potential challenges in terms of computational complexity and theoretical formulation, the opportunities for advancing our understanding of black holes and their dynamics are vast.
Read the original article
by jsendak | Feb 16, 2024 | GR & QC Articles
arXiv:2402.08704v1 Announce Type: new
Abstract: Motivated by high interest in Lorentz invariant massive gravity models known as dRGT massive gravity, we present an exact phantom black hole solution in this theory of gravity and discuss the thermodynamic structure of the black hole in the canonical ensemble. Calculating the conserved and thermodynamic quantities, we check the validity of the first law of thermodynamics and the Smarr relation in the extended phase space. In addition, we investigate both the local and global stability of these black holes and show how massive parameters affect the regions of stability. We extend our study to investigate the optical features of the black holes such as the shadow geometrical shape, energy emission rate, and deflection angle. Also, we discuss how these optical quantities are affected by massive coefficients. Finally, we consider a massive scalar perturbation minimally coupled to the background geometry of the black hole and examine the quasinormal modes (QNMs) by employing the WKB approximation.
Phantom Black Holes and the Thermodynamic Structure
In this article, we delve into the fascinating world of Lorentz invariant massive gravity models and specifically focus on the dRGT massive gravity theory. We start by presenting an exact solution for a phantom black hole within this theory and explore its thermodynamic structure in the canonical ensemble.
We aim to validate the first law of thermodynamics and the Smarr relation in the extended phase space by calculating the conserved and thermodynamic quantities associated with the black hole. This investigation will provide insights into the physical behavior and characteristics of these unique objects.
Stability Analysis and Dependence on Massive Parameters
To further our understanding, we also analyze the stability of these phantom black holes. Both local and global stability are examined, and we investigate how the massive parameters impact the regions of stability. This exploration will shed light on the conditions required for a stable black hole solution within the dRGT massive gravity framework.
Optical Features and Impact of Massive Coefficients
Expanding our study, we delve into the optical features of these black holes. We examine properties such as the shadow geometrical shape, energy emission rate, and deflection angle. By exploring how these optical quantities are influenced by the massive coefficients, we gain insights into the observable characteristics of these exotic objects.
Perturbations and Quasinormal Modes
Finally, we consider the effects of a massive scalar perturbation on the background geometry of the phantom black hole. By employing the WKB approximation, we examine the quasinormal modes (QNMs) associated with these perturbations. This analysis provides information about the vibrational behavior of these black holes and their response to external disturbances.
Future Roadmap: Challenges and Opportunities
Looking ahead, there are several challenges and opportunities on the horizon in this field of study. Some potential areas for exploration include:
- Further investigation into the thermodynamic properties of phantom black holes within different gravity theories.
- Extending the stability analysis to more complex black hole solutions and exploring the impact of additional parameters.
- Refining and expanding our understanding of the optical features of these black holes, including their detectability and potential implications for observational astronomy.
- Exploring the behavior of other types of perturbations, such as gravitational waves, and their interaction with the phantom black hole background.
By tackling these challenges and seizing these opportunities, we can continue to deepen our understanding of Lorentz invariant massive gravity models and their intriguing phantom black hole solutions. This research has the potential to advance our knowledge of fundamental physics and contribute to the broader field of theoretical astrophysics.
Read the original article
by jsendak | Jan 21, 2024 | GR & QC Articles
We investigate quasitopological black holes in $(2+1)$ dimensions in the
context of electromagnetic-generalized-quasitopological-gravities (EM-GQT). For
three different families of geometries of quasitopological nature, we study the
causal structure and their response to a probe scalar field. To linear order,
we verify that the scalar field evolves stably, decaying in different towers of
quasinormal modes. The studied black holes are either charged geometries
(regular and singular) or a regular Ba~nados-Teitelboim-Zanelli (BTZ)-like
black hole, both coming from the EM-GQT theory characterized by nonminimal
coupling parameters between gravity and a background scalar field. We calculate
the quasinormal modes applying different numerical methods with convergent
results between them. The oscillations demonstrate a very peculiar structure
for charged black holes: in the intermediate and near extremal cases, a
particular scaling arises, similar to that of the rotating BTZ geometry, with
the modes being proportional to the distance between horizons. For the single
horizon black hole solution, we identify the presence of different quasinormal
families by analyzing the features of that spectrum. In all three considered
geometries, no instabilities were found.
Based on our investigation, we have concluded that the quasitopological black holes in $(2+1)$ dimensions in the context of electromagnetic-generalized-quasitopological-gravities (EM-GQT) exhibit stable evolution of a probe scalar field. We have studied three different families of quasitopological geometries and have found that the scalar field decays in different towers of quasinormal modes.
The black holes we have examined can be classified as either charged geometries (regular and singular) or a regular Bañados-Teitelboim-Zanelli (BTZ)-like black hole. These black holes are derived from the EM-GQT theory, which includes nonminimal coupling parameters between gravity and a background scalar field.
In our calculations of the quasinormal modes, we have employed various numerical methods, all yielding convergent results. The oscillations of the modes in charged black holes exhibit a unique structure. In the intermediate and near extremal cases, a scaling proportional to the distance between horizons emerges, similar to that observed in the rotating BTZ geometry.
For the single horizon black hole solution, we have identified the presence of different quasinormal families by analyzing the characteristics of the spectrum. Importantly, we did not find any instabilities in any of the three considered geometries.
Future Roadmap
Challenges:
- Further investigation is needed to understand the causal structure and response of other fields, such as electromagnetic fields, to these quasitopological black holes in EM-GQT theory. The study of other probe fields may reveal additional insights and properties.
- Exploring the thermodynamic properties of these black holes can provide valuable information about their entropy, temperature, and thermodynamic stability. This analysis could involve studying thermodynamic quantities and phase transitions.
- Investigating the stability of these black holes under perturbations beyond linear order could uncover additional behavior and help to determine their long-term evolution.
Opportunities:
- The peculiar scaling observed in the oscillations of charged black holes could lead to new understandings of their underlying physical mechanisms. Further exploration of this scaling effect and its implications may offer insights into the connection between charge and geometry.
- The identification of different quasinormal families in the single horizon black hole solution presents an opportunity for studying the distinct characteristics and dynamics of these families. This information could contribute to a deeper understanding of black hole spectra in general.
- Extending the study to higher dimensions and different theories of gravity could provide valuable comparisons and insights into the behavior of quasitopological black holes across different contexts. Such investigations could include theories with additional matter fields or modified gravity theories.
In conclusion, the examination of quasitopological black holes in $(2+1)$ dimensions in the context of electromagnetic-generalized-quasitopological-gravities (EM-GQT) has revealed stable evolution and unique characteristics. While there are still challenges to address and opportunities to explore, this research lays the foundation for further expanding our understanding of these intriguing black hole solutions.
Reference:
Author(s): [Author names]
Journal: [Journal name]
Published: [Publication date]
DOI: [DOI number]
Read the original article
