Expert Commentary: Investigating Opacity for Stochastic Control Systems


This paper delves into the concept of opacity as an essential information-flow security property in stochastic control systems. Opacity determines whether a system can keep its critical behaviors, known as secret behaviors, hidden from external observers. Previous studies on opacity for control systems have provided a binary classification of security, focusing on whether a system is opaque or not. However, this paper takes a step further by introducing a quantifiable measure of opacity and proposes verification methods tailored to this new notion.

The Measure of Opacity for Stochastic Control Systems

The authors introduce a quantifiable measure of opacity for stochastic control systems modeled as general Markov decision processes (gMDPs). This measure considers the likelihood of satisfying opacity, providing a more nuanced perspective on the system’s security level. By taking into account the probability of preserving opacity, this measure enhances our understanding of the system’s overall behavior.

Verification Methods for Opacity in Finite gMDPs

To verify opacity in finite general Markov decision processes (gMDPs), the authors propose novel verification methods utilizing value iteration techniques. These methods are tailored to the specific characteristics and requirements of the new notions of opacity. By using these techniques, it becomes possible to analyze the security level of stochastic control systems and assess their adherence to opacity.

Approximate Opacity-Preserving Stochastic Simulation Relation

The paper introduces a new concept called the “approximate opacity-preserving stochastic simulation relation.” This notion captures the distance between two systems’ behaviors by evaluating their ability to preserve opacity. By quantifying this distance, it becomes possible to assess and compare the opacity-preserving capabilities of different systems. This relation proves useful in verifying opacity for stochastic control systems using their abstractions.

Application and Construction of Abstractions for gMDPs

To further facilitate the verification of opacity in stochastic control systems, the authors discuss the construction of abstractions for a specific class of general Markov decision processes (gMDPs) under stability conditions. These abstractions act as simplified models that retain the essential characteristics of the original system while reducing its complexity. By constructing suitable abstractions, the verification process becomes more efficient and feasible for large-scale models.


This paper presents a comprehensive investigation into opacity for stochastic control systems. By introducing a quantifiable measure of opacity, proposing tailored verification methods, and establishing the notion of an approximate opacity-preserving stochastic simulation relation, the authors contribute to a deeper understanding of system security. Furthermore, discussing the construction of abstractions for gMDPs provides practical insights for efficient verification processes. These advancements provide valuable tools for analyzing and ensuring information flow security in complex control systems.
Read the original article